Sunday, March 8, 2009

A Few More Lifebloom Calculations from the PTR

Raaff (Druid Heal!) threw some Lifebloom numbers out there first, looking at its new efficiency and throughput. His post left me asking two questions:
1. Does equipping 2pT7, which lowers the cost of Lifebloom have any affect on the amount of mana you get back when it blooms?
2. What is the throughput and efficiency of just Lifebloom? (Since Raaff's calculations were for a full reasonable cast cycle.)
Averna (Nerf this Druid) ran some numbers on throughput of Lifebloom alone. Her calculations included the bloom portion. This left me asking:
3. In a worst case scenario, or most like the current situation scenario, the bloom will all be overheal. What does this mean for Lifeblooms efficiency and throughput?
Scroll to the bottom to skips mathz and see conclusions.

This post has been highly inspired by Raaff and Averna and may subconsciously draw from their work, although I did all my own number crunching using my gear. If you haven't checked out their 3.1 PTR work yet, please do so.

Currently a Lifebloom cycle is 10 seconds long (with Glyph), costs 366 mana (with 2pT7), and a single Lifebloom ticks for 400 (for me), 800 for two, and 1200 for 3. I am going to ignore the mana cost and time to get the stack up, since most druids will not let that stack fall off the main tank.
Throughput:
1,200 HP ticks @ 1 tick/sec for 10 sec =
12,000 HP healed in a cycle
1,200 HP/10 sec = 1,200 HPS

Efficiency:
1 cast every 10 sec @ 366 mana/cast = 366 Mana spent in a cycle
12,000 HP/366 MP = 33 HPM
PTR Rolling (w 2pT7) The only change from the current numbers is that the cost will be 733 mana up from 366.
Throughput will remain the same: 1,200 HPS

Efficiency:
1 cast every 10 sec @ 733 mana/cast = 733 Mana spent in a cycle
12,000 HP/733 MP = 16 HPM
PTR Rolling (w/o 2pT7) The only change from the current numbers is that the cost will be 782 mana up from 366 (current) or 733 (w/ 2pT7).
Throughput will remain the same: 1,200 HPS

Efficiency:
1 cast every 10 sec @ 782 mana/cast = 782 Mana spent in a cycle
12,000 HP/782 MP = 15 HPM
PTR Blooming Overheal (w/ 2pT7) For this calculation I will assume that all of the Bloom over the healing done by a normal tick will go to overheal, since it is very difficult on most fights to predict damage 10 seconds into the future. A Lifebloom cycle is now 12 seconds long, since we need to rebuild our stack of 3. Half of mana refunded at the Bloom is equal to 1469 mana refunded.
Throughput:
1,200 @ 1 tick/sec for 10 sec = 12,000 HP
12,000 + 400
(1st tick) +800 (2nd tick) = 13,200 HP healed in a cycle
13,200 HP/ 13 sec = 1,015 HPS

Efficiency:
3 casts every 13 sec @ 733 mana/cast = 2,199 Mana spent in a cycle
2,199 mana spent - 1469 mana refunded = 730 Net Mana spent in a cycle
13,200 HP/730 MP = 18 HPM
PTR Blooming Overheal (w/o 2pT7) The same as the above calculation, except Lifebloom now costs 782 mana per cast.
Throughput will remain the same as above: 1,015 HPS

Efficiency:
3 casts every 13 sec @ 782 mana/cast = 2,346 Mana spent in a cylce
2,346 mana spent - 1469 mana refunded = 877 Net Mana spend in a cylce
13,200 HP/877 MP = 15 HPM
PTR Blooming Not Overhealed (w/ 2pT7) This is a calculation that is probably too good to be true. But once and a while we may get lucky and our entire bloom may go to effective healing. My bloom heals for 9703 HP.
Throughput:
400 (1st tick) + 800 (2nd tick) + 1,200*9 (ticks 3 though 11) + 9,703 (bloom) = 21,703 HP Healed in a cycle
21,703 HP/13 sec = 1,669 HPS

Efficiency:
3 casts every 13 sec @ 733 mana/cast = 2,199 Mana spent in a cycle
2,199 mana spent - 1469 mana refunded = 730 Net Mana spent in a cycle
21,702 HP/730 MP = 30 HPM
PTR Blooming Not Overhealed (w/o 2pT7) Same as above, but costs 782 mana per Lifebloom application.
Throughput will be the same as above: 1,669 HPS

Efficiency:
3 casts every 13 sec @ 782 mana/cast = 2,346 Mana spent in a cylce
2,346 mana spent - 1469 mana refunded = 877 Net Mana spend in a cylce
21,702 HP/877 MP = 25 HPM
Conclusions
1a. Equipping 2pT7 does not effect the amount of mana you get back when Lifebloom blooms. It was 1,469 mana returned with or without it. It makes casting Lifebloom 6% more efficient if you are rolling blooms and 20% more efficient if you are letting the blooms bloom. 4pT8 is going to have to be really really good to get Resto Druids to give up 2pT7.

2a. If your bloom is not overhealing, this will actually be a 39% buff to the throughput of Lifebloom. At least they threw us some consolation prize.

2b. Sadly, we are experiencing a 10% increase to the cost of Lifebloom. This is the best case scenario, if your bloom is going to effective healing.

3a. Throughput of Lifebloom ticks alone will drop 15%. This assumes all the bloom is overheal. I predict we will not notice any change in throughput for Lifebloom, since most of the time the bloom will be overheal, but once and a while it will actually contribute something. Your ability to predict the future... I mean damage... will make a big difference on how much of a nerf/buff this is to your Lifeblooms.

3b. The nerf could be as high as a 83% increase to cost. Again, your ability to predict the future will determine where you fall on the 10% to 83% cost increase spectrum. If you plan on rolling those blooms still, you are looking at a 106% increase, that you can do nothing about. Ouch!

Suggestions
1. Wear your 2pT7 until you absolutely have to break it. Make sure you are going into T8 with all 5 pieces of T7, even if you are not wearing them now. This will give you the most flexibility to keep the 2pT7 bonus as you pick up new pieces of gear after the patch.

2. Be prepared to not roll Lifeblooms. Start practicing now in heroics, 10 mans, and/or on 25 man trash. You have a bad habit to break, even though it was once good. This is like unlearning to brush your teeth in the morning and unlearning to put on your seat belt in the car. It will feel very very wrong, but it is the way to be mana efficient.

3. Whether this will be a nerf or a buff to your Lifebloom throughput and how badly of a nerf it will be to your efficiency will depend on your ability to predict damage. If you are not running BigWigs or Deadly Boss Mod timers, for heaven's sake get them. Practice now watching cool downs on abilities and finishing the three stack (ie adding the final LB to a stack of 2) 10 seconds before you know the tank will take increased damage. Some fights this will be impossible. Other fights it will just be freaking hard.

Any questions/comment/complaints welcome as always. I did most of this math on a note card waiting for Watchmen to start (good movie!) so I am very open to "Aert, you can't add here."

5 comments:

  1. Thanks for the number crunching on this. The suggestions are good. I've been doing a little practicing myself, but it's mostly just depressing. I'm hoping this goes through some changes on the ptr before it makes it to live realms. QQ.
    Sylly

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm just guessing/dreaming here, but....

    Start a fight with 1-2 lifebloom(s) on the tank, just before the tank charges in. Proceed to cast Rejuv and wait. Tank will proceed to take big damage from the crowd (depending on gear but you know how it will go from experience) Rejuv will soften the blows but the tank will quickly/somewhat fall to that damage gap before the bloom occurs. Thus instant big heal with tank getting more aggro for the bloom. (It still works like that right? Which would be beneficial if you are running with a Bear) Then I would proceed to place a three stack with a rejuv/regrowth.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for the theorycrafting and math, Aertimus. It'll be interesting to see how we cope with this when/if it finally goes live.
    I have written about it too, but it was more of a rant and gut feeling than true analysis.

    Running Elk
    runningelk.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. Argh, math! Brain overload :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. What I don't get is, this seems like a huge buff to raid healing with lifebloom. You get back half of the base cost of the spell, but the spell only costs you 75% of the base cost (tol and 2t7). So you "invest" 150% of the base cost of lifebloom, and then get back 100% of the base cost of LB when it blooms. This means that when raid healing with LB, it now costs 50% after 9/10 seconds...seems like a huge buff to mana efficiency.

    Pay 733 mana, get 489 back, and the net cost is 243.75 mana. Maybe people aren't saying this very loud, but i think it is a neat dynamic.

    ReplyDelete

Followers

About Amy

I've been playing WoW since Easter Sunday 2005, coincidentally the same day I became engaged to my forever husband and tank Chad, aka Yakra. I have held the roles of druid class officer, healing role officer, and general secretarial type officer in two guilds. Currently, I am not playing WoW. When I'm playing, my blog, like my life, is casualcore PvE healing focused. (I love gear math!) When I'm not playing WoW... well, I can't quite tell you what this blog will be about since I have never blogged while not playing WoW! Expect to see reflections on being a married WoW player and on just being married, stories from my other RP adventures (LARPing and table top), and accounts of my life's most meaningful activity: teaching chemistry.





Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License.

E-mail icon created at Nexodyne